Ahhh the Magpie is seafood heaven. The mussels are to die for. Amazing. Stayed in Whitby for a few nights at the beginning of this month and we ended up going 3 times. Ambiente is really, really nice. I was never a sherry fan but I am quite partial to a couple of glasses when I go there. Best to go in the afternoon I think, quieter. Otherwise you have to book if you want to go in the evening. Lemongrass meatballs...weird, but delicious!